Siniora orders Nahr al-Bared rebuild to continue
Work to resume despite ruins following silent expiry of Shura Council injunction
By Michael Bluhm
Daily Star staff
Saturday, October 24, 2009
BEIRUT: The government has ordered that all reconstruction work resume at the war-scarred Nahr al-Bared Palestinian refugee camp, as a State Shura Council injunction stopping part of the rebuilding expired this month without the council making a final ruling.
Caretaker Prime Minister Fouad Siniora informed Palestinian representatives on Friday that his administration had instructed the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) the day before to restart the reconstruction project in dispute, despite the possibility that the council might still decide for a permanent halt to the process, said Nahr al-Bared Reconstruction Commission chairman Marwan Abdel-Aal, who met with Siniora on Friday.
The State Shura Council had issued an injunction on August 13 suspending part of the rebuilding efforts for two months, in a decision that sparked a wave of protest by the camp’s displaced former residents and Palestinians throughout Lebanon.
The council declared the halt on the basis of a petition submitted by Free Patriotic Movement (FPM) head MP Michel Aoun, who asked the council to end backfilling – the process of rebuilding over and yet preserving ancient artifacts unearthed under the camp – in order to protect the antiquities at the site.
The sensitive legal issue does not concern only archaeology, because if the State Shura Council rules in favor of Aoun’s suit and prohibits backfilling, UNRWA will have to rebuild much of the camp on a different site, meaning many of Nahr al-Bared’s some 31,000 registered residents would never return to their homes. Much of the camp was destroyed in a three-month battle between the Lebanese Armed Forces and Fatah al-Islam militants in mid-2007.
UNRWA will resume the backfilling process early next week, said UNRWA spokeswoman Hoda al-Turk.
“We were requested to stop for two months, and two months are over now,” she said. “We’re complying with the Lebanese law.”
Constitutional law professor Shafik Masri said the government was not violating the law by renewing the disputed reconstruction before the State Shura Council makes a final ruling. The temporary injunction has expired, and the council has neither issued a verdict nor extended the prohibition on backfilling, he added.
“It’s a question of no follow-up and no decision,” he said. “It’s not actually a question of wrong or right.
“The government can resume its construction, because it’s not forbidden,” Masri added.
In addition, Aoun could have submitted reminders asking the council to prolong the ban on backfilling past the original two-month suspension, Masri said. FPM representatives did not respond on Friday to repeated requests for comment.
Aoun’s filing and the council’s August decision triggered a flood of criticism, with some advocates of the rebuilding questioning the sincerity of Aoun’s interest in preserving the country’s archaeological heritage. Government representatives said it would be impossible to rebuild in the area adjacent to the camp, as Aoun proposed, or anywhere but on the site of the original camp.
Demonstrations protesting the council’s injunction took place at Nahr al-Bared, in Tripoli and Beirut, as well as in the Ain al-Hilweh, Al-Buss and Shatila refugee camps.
The council’s injunction only added to the skepticism over the reconstruction among some Nahr al-Bared displaced residents, who have long voiced fears that the state would never allow them to rebuild their camp, similar to the fate of the Tell Zaatar camp leveled during the 1975-90 Civil War.
UNRWA’s $445-million rebuilding plans call for the camp to be completely reconstructed by April 2012, and UNRWA’s Turk said the delay in backfilling had not put the project far behind schedule.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment